Articles

Peer Feedback in Writing: Problems and Prospects

  • Many researchers have strongly recommended peer feedback as the crucial step in process writing approach. It refers to the ability of a learner to provide advice on the learning outcomes of peers from the aspects of the level, value, quantity, and quality (Topping, 1998). It can be explained as one of the learning activity based on constructivism. It has been shown from several studies that positive roles are played by peer feedback in teaching and learning. Peer feedback enables the students to get feedback from their peers (a more diverse audience) to bring multiple perspectives and to help student gain more confidence. This helps the students improve their writing skills, enhance their learning motivation, improve their critical thinking skills, stimulate students' interest in learning and serve them to acquire a lifelong learning skill.

     

    Problems of peer feedback

     

    Though there are many advantages of peer feedback, it also has some problems in a teaching environment. Firstly, students may lack confidence in whether they can provide specific and qualified feedback. Mostly, teachers are the only set of people to give feedback to students' homework. Once teachers make any form of a comment on students' homework, they can change the students' mind – this will make students doubt if they can substitute their teachers' feedback with their peers with specific and qualified feedback. Students' believe that teachers are superior to the students in the aspects of professional knowledge.

     

    Secondly, most of the students don’t trust peer feedback. Their teachers' authority is what they worship, and they rely on the teacher's commentary – this makes them skeptical about peers' ability to give feedback and thereby distrust their peers' feedback. This happens especially to peers they consider as lower competence students.

     

    Thirdly, Students believe that positive feedback is absent in peer feedback. This is one of the results of most researchers as they have considered feedback as error correction. This result also affects students profoundly. Most of the peer feedbacks are based only on the shortcomings and errors of companions' writings – this makes a comment full of correction and criticism and lack of encouragement. Comments of this nature affect peer's confidence and interest in learning, and it will also affect student's utilization of feedback from a peer. Solutions to these problems will increase the effectiveness of peer feedback as they all affect peer feedback.

     

    Improving the application of feedback

     

    One primary key to helping students build enough confidence in giving feedback is to put them through peer feedback training. Most researchers have discovered that providing students feedback training can improve the feedback quality, reduce the influence of subjective factors on peer review, and make the feedback more efficient. Students may feel that they are more confident to provide quality feedback for a company since they can provide more specific advice to their peers.

     

    There are four steps to ensure a peer feedback training: firstly, emphasize the function and significance of peer feedback to the students. They should know what peer feedback entails as it will enable them to receive comments from diverse way – with enough benefits to their learning. Secondly, you will have to provide feasible evaluation criterion. This will allow the student to understand how to comment a peer's writing, and it will make them have faith in their ability to give feedback to peers. There will improve the reliability of peer feedback when they are provided with evaluation criterion. The third step is to explain the evaluation criterion with the use of some examples and lastly, demonstrate to the students how to give peer feedback. Teachers can select students’ work as example randomly.

     

    References

     

    Cresswell, A. (2003) Self-monitoring in student writing: developing learner responsibility. ELT Journal 54 (3), 235-244.

     

    Lee, I. (1998) Supporting greater autonomy in language teaching. ELT Journal 52 (4), 282-289.

     

    Omelicheva,M. Y. (2005) Self and Peer Evaluation in Undergraduate Education: Structuring Conditions That Maximize Its Promises and Minimize the Perils. Journal of Political Science Education 1 (2), 191-205.

     

    Topping, K. (1998) Peer assessment between students in college and universities. Review of Educational Research 68 (3), 249-276.

     

    Stanley, J. (1992) Coaching Student Writers to Be Effective Peer Evaluators. Journal of Second Language Writing 1 (3), 217-233.

     

    Freeman, M. (1995) Peer assessment by groups of group work. Assessment and Evaluation in Higher Education, 20, 289-300.

     

    Min, H. T. (2005) Training students to become successful peer feedbackers. System 33 (2), 293-308.

     

    Min, H. T. (2006) The effects of trained peer feedback on EFL students’ revision types and writing quality. Journal of Second Language Writing 15 (2), 118-141.

Comments

3 comments
  • Penprofile and Rahmatu Lawan like this
  • Michael Rickard
    Michael Rickard This article gave me a lot to consider. What do you think is an appropriate grade level for students to use peer feedback? Also, have you experienced situations where students are afraid to give negative feedback because they fear a backlash or don't...  more
    December 19, 2017 - 1 likes this
  • Lady Grasha
    Lady Grasha Students really have trouble trusting peer feedbacks. As a school teacher, I've tried countless times to inculcate the idea of believing in peers but they seem to only want to get responses from people they feel have higher authority. I think a training...  more
  • Kathy James
    Kathy James I think that I would struggle to give negative feedback to someone especially if I have to see them everyday in class. Additionally I think that within the high school age, people might give positive feedback if they are friends and perhaps negative...  more
    May 29

Recent Articles

  • How taking a gap year volunteering can be beneficial to your study

    Posted Jun 4

    Many students worry about taking a gap year thinking that it will look like they have taken a year-long holiday. But what if I told you how it could be beneficial to your further education. Volunteering while taking a gap year from your studies is often used to enrich a...

  • 9 photos that describe the state of primary school education in Nigeria

    Posted May 15

    Primary education is the foundation of educational pursuits. If the foundation is strong, whatever is built upon will stand the test of time, and if it doesn't, inevitably it will collapse.   The four cardinal points of education – writing, reading, speakin...

  • Five Essential Time Management Tips for Students

    Posted May 4

    As a university or college student, time management is one of the most critical tools for academic success. You may be studying and working, or even have a family that looks up to you for their needs - how do you strike a balance between work and school without jeopardi...

  • If I Can Make Some Cash Writing Online, You Can, Too

    Posted May 3

    I have been keeping a blog for a long time now. I just usually from time to time log in, tweak some few features for hours while writing next to nothing, and log out. I have a few reads and fewer comments on that blog, and why not? There was nothing substantial to read....

View All

Random Articles

  • 3 Ways to Secure Employment before Graduating From the University

    Posted January 20, 2017

    Looking at the unemployment rate in several countries all over the world, the job market has gotten increasingly tough for fresh graduates to stand out and get their dream job.   For those graduates who think outside the box, there are still ways to get ahead of ...

  • Some Tips on Designing Scientific Research

    Posted June 12, 2017

    Given that Scientific Research plays a major role within the research community, it becomes imperative to get hold up what constitutes its design. A proper approach to research shows a more defined path to figuring out the right things. Good research will take you a lon...

  • A Discourse on Zakaat, Sadaqah and Income Tax (1)

    Posted June 20, 2017

    Introduction   Zakaat, Sadaaqah and Income Tax are all forms of financial obligations demanded from the citizens of a country or people generally either by a government/social institution, religious institution or out of philanthropy. Though they have many simila...

  • Different Ways to Engage Students in Class

    Posted October 8, 2017

    The first and the most challenging task for a teacher is to get his students focused, and develop their interest in his lecture. Once he has locked the students in his lecture, watching them lose their concentration is equally problematic. Still, unless a teacher manage...

View All